Tell Your Story with Timelines

 

Now that we are coming out of the pandemic and going back into the courtroom, it’s wise to start considering how best to persuade jurors.

An obvious point: the more complex the case, the more important it is that you simplify and clarify events and circumstances for the jurors. A timeline is one of the most effective ways to organize facts in a way that makes them relevant to jurors. We are used to stories being presented chronologically. The chronology alone often will tell the story. Use a timeline, or several, whenever possible. 

Timelines, whether on a board or projected onto a screen, should be presented with time on the horizontal axis whenever possible. It demonstrates the movement of time from left to right, a progression jurors are very familiar with. When presented with a timeline depicting time on a vertical axis, often favored by attorneys, jurors can be too easily confused.

A horizontal timeline also allows you to show events above and below the line representing time, be that in minutes, days or years. This is a very effective way to organize information. You can, for example, show the evidence that directly favors your case in “flags” above the date line, and show the inconsistencies in opposing counsel’s case in the flags below the date line. For example, as defense, you can contrast plaintiff’s stated behavior at points in time on the above the line flags, with the contradictory medical reports on the below the line flags. 

Timelines of any kind should be used creatively, not just as markers in time, but as ways to tell your story more persuasively.